October 8, 2015 | Daniel Rutman

Why a Shareholders’ Agreement is crucial for your Company.

Why a Shareholders’ Agreement is crucial for your Company

A Company with two or more shareholders should have a Shareholders’ Agreement. The Shareholders' Agreement provides a framework to navigate within regarding the shareholder's rights and obligations, and the protection of the interests of all the shareholders in the event of changing circumstances.

The agreement should provide guidelines about how the ownership of the company will operate, including an outline of the funding of share transfers, management rights, dividend policies and details of how equity will be provided to employees. As well as setting parameters for company operations, the overview helps guide shareholders through issues not dealt with elsewhere in the agreement.

Some other key considerations to include in a shareholders’ agreement for your company:

How are the Company’s shares valued? This price is critical to a wide range of actions, including issuing new shares and shareholder sales. There are several valuation methods such as capitalisation of earnings, discounted cashflows and net tangible assets. All are subjective – different external valuers can come up with different valuations of the same company, so the agreement should specify an agreed methodology.

Did you know there are several exit strategies available for shareholders to buy and sell their shares? Setting out formal processes that govern how shareholders can exit the business and at what price, can remove a major source of contention in private company ownership. The sale process should give existing shareholders pre-emptive rights to purchase the stake before it can be sold to an outsider using the valuation method set out in the agreement. Should the partners refuse this “first right” to buy, then the selling partner can then find a third-party buyer at the same (or higher) asking price.

What happens in the event of death or disability? How are the Shares handled? How do existing partners protect the company? The shareholder agreement can ensure shareholders are able to afford to purchase the stakes of co-owners in the event of death or disability, by funding such a sale through linked life and trauma insurance. The death of an owner can cause problems for private companies – relatives may wish to realise inherited company shareholdings, thus requiring other shareholders to raise finance or face the prospect of the stake being sold to an outsider. The shareholder agreement can stipulate that each owner should take out life and trauma insurance to the benefit of other shareholders, which then provides finance to buy the stake in event of death.

How are Dividends Paid? Set out how often dividends will be paid and how their value will be determined (e.g., as a percentage of net profits). The agreement should say when they are not to be paid – such as when working capital is required and liquidity ratios have fallen below a threshold.

What happens when you cannot agree? The Agreement doesn’t handle your particular problem? Although the agreement should stem most possible sources of conflict between shareholders, it should also anticipate that owners may disagree occasionally and provide a mechanism to resolve differences. The most common approach is to nominate a third-party mediator.

We’ve only discussed a few considerations when putting together your company’s shareholders’ agreement. Let’s discuss in detail: call our offices 905-456-9969 or email ruby@rutmanlaw.com.

Recent Blogs / News

  • February 18, 2026 | Daniel Rutman

    Ontario ESA Leave of Absence Guide for Employees

    Balancing work and personal life is essential. As important as it is to stay committed at work, it’s important to take time for yourself and handle personal responsibilities when life demands it.  There are times when your health needs attention, your family needs support, or unexpected and unavoidable situations arise. During these times, you shouldn’t have to worry about your job security. That’s why Ontario provides job-protected leaves under the Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA), so employees can step away when necessary and return without risking their employment. There are limits on the types of leave you can apply for under Ontario's employment policy. Let’s understand everything about leave of absence in Ontario as per Ontario’s Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA). What Is a Leave of Absence in Ontario? A leave of absence means that you can take time off work while keeping your employment status active. These leaves are...

    Read More
  • February 17, 2026 | Daniel Rutman

    Right To Disconnect Ontario: Guide For Employees and Employers

    Employees are not always comfortable replying to work emails and messages even after their working hours have ended. With phones and laptops always nearby, the boundary between work and personal time has become blurred. Over time, this constant connectivity can affect both work-life balance and overall well-being. As these concerns became more common across workplaces in the province, clearer rules were introduced to address after-hours communication and employer expectations. In Ontario, some employers must have a written Right to Disconnect policy that explains after-hours communication, but it doesn’t stop them from contacting you after work. This guide explains everything employees and employers need to know about the policy. What is the Right to Disconnect? The Ontario “Right to Disconnect” policy was introduced by the provincial government on December 2, 2021, under the Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA). Under the policy, employees may disconnect from work after working hours. The purpose...

    Read More
  • October 27, 2025 | Daniel Rutman

    Do I Qualify for Severance Pay in Ontario? ESA & Common Law (2025 Guide)

    Losing your job can be one of the most traumatic experiences in your professional life. Whether it is a result of restructuring, downsizing, or any other non-disciplinary reason, it is important to understand your rights - particularly regarding severance pay in Ontario. A number of employees do not know they might be entitled to compensation beyond basic termination pay. This guide explains who gets severance pay under the ESA, how it differs under common law, and when to speak to a severance lawyer. What is Severance Pay in Ontario? Severance pay is compensation offered at termination without cause after a lengthy relationship. It is meant to acknowledge the years of service and to assist with financial support while one looks for work. In Ontario, severance pay can be calculated in two ways: According to the Employment Standards Act (ESA), which is the minimum standard. According to common law, which often...

    Read More
View All

If you Liked This, You Might Also Like These

February 18, 2026| Daniel Rutman

Ontario ESA Leave of Absence Guide for Employees

Balancing work and personal life is essential. As important as it is to stay committed at work, it’s important to take time for yourself and handle personal responsibilities when life demands it.  There are times when your health needs attention, your family needs support, or unexpected and unavoidable situations arise. During these times, you shouldn’t have to worry about your job security. That’s why Ontario provides job-protected leaves under the Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA), so employees can step away when necessary and return without risking their employment. There are limits on the types of leave you can apply for under Ontario's employment policy. Let’s understand everything about leave of absence in Ontario as per Ontario’s Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA). What Is a Leave of Absence in Ontario? A leave of absence means that you can take time off work while keeping your employment status active. These leaves are...

Read More
February 17, 2026| Daniel Rutman

Right To Disconnect Ontario: Guide For Employees and Employers

Employees are not always comfortable replying to work emails and messages even after their working hours have ended. With phones and laptops always nearby, the boundary between work and personal time has become blurred. Over time, this constant connectivity can affect both work-life balance and overall well-being. As these concerns became more common across workplaces in the province, clearer rules were introduced to address after-hours communication and employer expectations. In Ontario, some employers must have a written Right to Disconnect policy that explains after-hours communication, but it doesn’t stop them from contacting you after work. This guide explains everything employees and employers need to know about the policy. What is the Right to Disconnect? The Ontario “Right to Disconnect” policy was introduced by the provincial government on December 2, 2021, under the Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA). Under the policy, employees may disconnect from work after working hours. The purpose...

Read More
October 27, 2025| Daniel Rutman

Do I Qualify for Severance Pay in Ontario? ESA & Common Law (2025 Guide)

Losing your job can be one of the most traumatic experiences in your professional life. Whether it is a result of restructuring, downsizing, or any other non-disciplinary reason, it is important to understand your rights - particularly regarding severance pay in Ontario. A number of employees do not know they might be entitled to compensation beyond basic termination pay. This guide explains who gets severance pay under the ESA, how it differs under common law, and when to speak to a severance lawyer. What is Severance Pay in Ontario? Severance pay is compensation offered at termination without cause after a lengthy relationship. It is meant to acknowledge the years of service and to assist with financial support while one looks for work. In Ontario, severance pay can be calculated in two ways: According to the Employment Standards Act (ESA), which is the minimum standard. According to common law, which often...

Read More
Contact-us Image

Get in touch with us

Request A Consultation

Contact-us Image

Are you stuck with a legal issue? Don't navigate the complexities alone! Turn to our top-rated lawyers for expert guidance and support, ensuring you make informed decisions every step of the way!

Request A Consultation